When planning a luxury vacation, one of the first decisions travelers face is whether to go all-inclusive or choose a pay-as-you-go approach. While both options have their perks, your choice can significantly impact your overall experience, budget, and relaxation level.
So, which option is best for luxury travel? Let’s break down the differences, advantages, and potential drawbacks to help you decide—and share some insider all-inclusive travel tips along the way.
Lounge chairs on white sand facing the sea
Secrets Akumal Riviera Maya
The all-inclusive experience: effortless luxury
All-inclusive travel isn’t just about convenience; it’s about stepping into a world where everything has been thoughtfully curated for your enjoyment. From gourmet dining and premium cocktails to daily activities and spa discounts, luxury all-inclusive resorts take the guesswork out of vacation planning.
Imagine this: You arrive at Secrets Moxché Playa del Carmen, and within minutes, you’re greeted with a welcome drink and a personal concierge who handles everything—spa reservations, dinner plans, and even arranging a private snorkeling excursion.
Lobby Arrival View
Secrets Moxche Playa del Carmen
Pros of all-inclusive travel:
- Cost predictability: You know upfront what your vacation will cost, with meals, drinks, entertainment, and even some activities included.
- Seamless relaxation: No need to carry cash or calculate expenses. Everything is handled with a simple wristband or room number.
- Exclusive amenities: Top-tier resorts offer luxurious extras like swim-up suites, hydrotherapy circuits, and gourmet dining experiences.
Cons of all-inclusive travel:
- Limited exploration: Guests sometimes feel less inclined to leave the property to explore local attractions.
- Not all resorts are equal: The “all-inclusive” label varies widely; choosing a reputable brand like those available through Unlimited Vacation Club (UVC) ensures quality.
Tip: To get the most out of your all-inclusive vacation, book a Preferred Club or Xhale Club suite, which often includes access to private lounges, upgraded amenities, and personalized concierge services.
The pay-as-you-go approach: personalized and flexible
The pay-as-you-go model appeals to travelers who want more control over their itinerary and spending. It works particularly well for city breaks or destinations where local dining and activities are the main attraction.
Imagine this: You’re in Puerto Vallarta, staying in a boutique hotel and dining at different taco stands and high-end restaurants each night, paying only for what you consume.
Pros of pay-as-you-go travel:
- Total flexibility: You choose exactly where and when you eat, drink, and explore.
- Customized experiences: If you love discovering hidden restaurants or booking unique tours independently, this model gives you freedom.
- Better for short city stays: Ideal for weekend getaways where you plan to be out and about most of the time.
Cons of pay-as-you-go travel:
- Unpredictable costs: Meals, drinks, and activities add up quickly—especially in tourist-heavy areas.
- Less convenience: Constantly calculating expenses and making reservations can feel like work.
- Fewer perks: Luxury hotels often reserve their best services for all-inclusive guests.
Tip: If you go the pay-as-you-go route, set a daily budget and research restaurants and activities ahead of time to avoid overspending.
Comparing experiences: which is right for you?
1. Dining and drinks
- All-inclusive: Imagine dining at eight different restaurants without worrying about the bill. At Dreams Bahia Mita Surf & Spa Resort, you can enjoy gourmet French cuisine one night and authentic Mexican flavors the next—all included.
- Pay-as-you-go: You have the freedom to try local eateries and high-end restaurants. But after a few $20 cocktails and $100 dinners, you might wish you’d opted for an all-inclusive plan.
Verdict: If you love variety and don’t want to think about costs, all-inclusive wins. If you’re in a culinary hotspot like Mexico City, pay-as-you-go is better for exploring the local food scene.
Himitsu, a japanese restaurant
Dreams Bahia Mita Surf & Spa Resort
2. Activities and entertainment
- All-inclusive: Resorts like Secrets Puerto Los Cabos Golf & Spa Resort offer daily entertainment, fitness classes, snorkeling, and even tequila tastings—all included.
- Pay-as-you-go: You’ll pay for each tour or activity separately, and popular excursions can cost anywhere from $50 to $200 per person.
Verdict: All-inclusive is better for travelers who enjoy a mix of relaxation and activities without planning everything in advance.
Fitness center
Secrets Puerto Los Cabos Golf & Spa Resort
3. Spa and wellness
- All-inclusive: Wellness-focused resorts like Secrets Maroma Beach Riviera Cancun often include hydrotherapy circuits and fitness classes as part of the package, with discounts on spa treatments.
- Pay-as-you-go: Spa services are typically charged at premium rates, and wellness classes often come with additional fees.
Verdict: If wellness is a priority, all-inclusive provides better value and more options.
Indoor massage cabanas
Secrets Maroma Beach Riviera Cancun
The hidden costs: what travelers often overlook
Hidden costs of all-inclusive travel:
- Premium experiences: Not all resorts include specialty restaurants or top-shelf liquor in their base package.
- Excursions: Off-site tours often carry an extra charge.
- Spa treatments: Massages and beauty services usually come with an added cost, unless part of a package.
Hidden costs of pay-as-you-go travel:
- Service charges: Tourist hotspots often add 10-20% service fees.
- Transportation: Taxis and rideshares between restaurants, attractions, and the hotel can quickly add up.
- Last-minute bookings: Booking tours or restaurants on the fly often comes with premium rates.
How to maximize an all-inclusive vacation: expert travel tips
- Book through Unlimited Vacation Club: Members enjoy access to top-tier resorts with guaranteed amenities and exclusive discounts.
- Use the member portal: Check for promotions like free nights, suite upgrades, or complimentary spa treatments.
- Explore beyond the resort: While all-inclusive properties offer plenty to do, venture out on a guided tour to experience local culture.
- Request a room upgrade at check-in: UVC members often receive priority for upgrades when available.
Pro tip: If you’re staying at a resort like Secrets Moxché Playa del Carmen, ask about the chef’s table experience—a hidden gem that takes all-inclusive dining to a new level.
Bisou – French Restaurant
Secrets Moxche Playa del Carmen
How to make pay-as-you-go work for luxury travel
- Plan activities in advance: Book tours and experiences online to secure better rates.
- Set a daily budget: It’s easy to overspend on dining and drinks without a plan.
- Mix high and low: Enjoy fine dining one night, and visit a casual local spot the next.
Consider a hybrid approach: Some resorts offer partial all-inclusive plans that let you enjoy amenities while still exploring independently.
The verdict: which option suits you best?
- Choose all-inclusive if:
- You want to fully relax without worrying about costs.
- You plan to spend most of your time at the resort.
- You love having a wide variety of dining and activity options.
- Choose pay-as-you-go if:
- You enjoy planning and customizing your experiences.
- You’re staying in a location with a vibrant local dining scene.
- You don’t plan to spend much time at the hotel.
The best of both worlds: UVC resorts that offer it all
The beauty of Unlimited Vacation Club is that it offers flexible, all-inclusive experiences at luxury resorts throughout Mexico and the Caribbean. Whether you want a laid-back wellness retreat in Isla Mujeres, an adventure-filled escape in Los Cabos, or a vibrant social getaway in Cancun, you’ll find a resort that fits your travel style.
So, next time you’re planning a luxurious getaway, weigh the convenience of all-inclusive with the freedom of pay-as-you-go. And remember, with the right all-inclusive travel tips, you can turn a good vacation into an extraordinary one.
Terms and conditions may vary depending on the membership contracted.